{ 07 } - The order of operations
Can't meditate? You might need regulation instead.
Anxious · 4 min read · The move: regulate first, then sit
I tried every meditation app. Ten minutes of sitting still while my heart hammered and a calm voice told me to notice my thoughts. I noticed them. There were thousands. Then I felt like I'd failed at the one thing that was supposed to help. The problem wasn't effort. It was order of operations.
In short
Meditation trains attention and is easier when your body is already fairly settled. Somatic regulation starts with the body: a long exhale, shaking or rhythmic left-right movement can shift the state before you sit. If sitting still makes you more agitated, regulate first.
Meditation starts with the mind
Meditation is a practice for a body that is already fairly settled. It trains attention. It's genuinely useful, and it's nearly impossible to do while your nervous system is in alarm, because attention is the first thing alarm takes away.
Regulation starts with the body
Somatic regulation goes the other way round. It uses the body to change the state, and lets the mind follow. A long exhale slows the heart. Shaking discharges the fuel that anger loaded you with. Rhythmic left-right movement gives a spinning system something to lock onto. None of it requires you to be calm first. That's the point.
The tell
How to know which you need.
- Sitting still makes you more agitated.
- 'Just breathe' makes you want to throw the phone.
- You leave a meditation more wound up than you started.
- Any of those: regulate first. Once the body is inside its window, meditation becomes possible, and sometimes unnecessary.
In Regulate: not meditation. Regulation.
Regulate is a set of short, physical tools for the three states your body actually gets stuck in, with a check-in first so you get the right one. Some take thirty seconds. Most involve moving. None ask you to sit still and wait for calm to arrive.
Questions people ask
Why can't I meditate when I'm anxious?
Alarm takes attention away, so sitting still with a racing body can feel impossible. The issue may be order, not effort.
What is the difference between meditation and somatic regulation?
Meditation starts with the mind and trains attention. Somatic regulation starts with the body and lets the mind follow.
Should I regulate before meditation?
If sitting still makes you more agitated, regulate first. Once the body is inside its window, meditation becomes possible, and sometimes unnecessary.
Sources
Evidence: Moderate
Regulate is a nervous system regulation app for iOS. Not meditation. Regulation.
Get the app